
Financial Planning Questions
Most misunderstandings come from one thing:
People think pension is a simple formula based on final salary alone
When it’s actually a multi-variable system involving timing, earnings structure, and tier rules
Here are the most common misunderstandings NYC law enforcement members (NYPD especially) have about their pension and retirement planning. These come up repeatedly in real retirement calculations and counseling conversations:
Handling Resistance
Common responses:
“I’ll deal with it at 20.”
“I have a pension, I’m fine.”
“I don’t trust financial guys.”
1) “My pension is based on my last paycheck”
This is one of the biggest misconceptions.
In reality, your pension is based on your Final Average Salary (FAS), which is usually:
-
The average of your highest earning 36 months (Tier 3/4/6 rules vary slightly depending on classification and service history)
-
Not just your last paycheck
-
And not just base salary either (some overtime may count, but not all and not equally)
Why it matters:
People assume a last-year push in overtime = huge pension jump. It often doesn’t scale the way they expect.
2) “All overtime boosts my pension equally”
Not true.
Only pensionable earnings count toward FAS, and:
-
Some overtime is included (especially regular recurring OT)
-
Some is capped or averaged in a way that reduces its impact
-
Sporadic “spike OT” is often adjusted downward in retirement calculations
Result: people overestimate OT impact on lifetime pension.
3) “Once I hit 20 or 22 years, I should retire immediately”
This is a timing misconception.
While eligibility starts around those milestones (depending on tier), retirement timing affects:
-
Step increases
-
Longevity pay
-
Terminal leave
-
Pension “final averaging window”
Sometimes working 6–18 more months can significantly increase lifetime pension value, and sometimes it doesn’t—depends on salary structure at the time.
4) “My pension is guaranteed to be 50%+ no matter what”
Not automatically.
Your benefit depends on:
-
Tier (Tier 2/4/6 differences are huge)
-
Years of service
-
Final average salary
-
Retirement type (service vs disability vs deferred)
Some members are surprised when their actual percentage is lower than what they “heard on the job.”
5) “Health insurance is automatic and unchanged”
Retiree health coverage is often misunderstood.
Key issues:
-
You must meet service requirements to qualify for full retiree health benefits
-
Contributions can change after retirement
-
Medicare coordination becomes a factor later
Many assume “I’m covered forever at no cost,” which is not always accurate.
6) “Unused sick time just disappears”
Not true—but it’s also not always fully understood.
Typically:
-
Sick time can be converted into service credit or terminal leave
-
But it does NOT always convert 1:1 into pension value
-
Timing of retirement can affect how it’s applied
-
7) “My pension is taxed the same everywhere”
Federal tax rules apply, but:
-
NY State treatment differs depending on residency and pension exclusion rules
-
Where you retire (NY vs out of state) can affect net income significantly
-
8) “Disability retirement is always financially better”
Not necessarily.
There are tradeoffs:
-
Service retirement may produce higher long-term income
-
Disability has eligibility requirements and limitations
-
Some benefits change (COLA timing, offsets, etc.)